Heartland Rock Piano

As the piano is my favourite instrument and I listen to a lot of heartland rock, I decided to write an article discussing the heartland rock piano sound. I mention the use of piano in heartland rock songs ranging from big hits to album tracks. I’ll start with the song “American Storm” by Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band. Bill’s piano contributes wonderfully to the full band sound with his playing. The piano notes go up the scale in a very heartland rock way. In their other song “The Ring”, it’s led by the piano of Silver Bullet Band keyboardist Craig Frost. Craig brings an epic feel with his playing and has two solos. The Ring fuses heartland rock with pop rock.

The Ring - Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band (1986)

Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers had a piano-driven hit “Don't Do Me Like That”. Keyboardist Benmont Tench gives a memorable jolly piano part. Nearly a decade later, their song “Jammin’ Me” is a different type of heartland rock song. Benmont brings rock & roll piano sounds into a heartland rock setting. I love what the piano does in the chorus. In Billy Joel’s hit “Allentown”, he leads the song greatly with his piano playing. There is a great piano riff throughout the song.

Don’t Do Me Like That - Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers (1979)

Cleveland heartland rock singer Michael Stanley had released music both with the Michael Stanley Band and solo. When keyboardist Kevin Raleigh joined the band, he was a songwriter and co-lead singer. The songs I’m featuring have two keyboardists Kevin Raleigh and Bob Pelander. They both contributed piano and I don’t know who was the piano player for each song. I wonder if Kevin played piano on the songs he wrote and Bob played the piano on the songs Michael wrote. Last Night, written by both Michael and Kevin is opened by the piano which has a majestic presence on this song. There is a section in the song where the piano notes go up and down in an epic rocking way.

Last Night - Michael Stanley Band (1979)

Promises, a Kevin Raleigh written song has the verses sung by Michael with the choruses seemingly sung by both Kevin and Michael. The piano is lively and energetic. There is a nice glissando after the first chorus. The song “Lover” has a nice piano riff which comes in following the guitar intro. The piano part isn’t the loudest, but it contributes greatly to the song’s sound. My Town is an epic rocker about Michael’s hometown. While this is a guitar-driven song, the piano provides good support including prominent notes during the choruses. How Can You Call This Love written and sung by Kevin has powerful rocking piano playing. The piano goes fast with deep notes.

How Can You Call This Love - Michael Stanley Band (1983)

Bruce Springsteen’s piano player Roy Bittan played wonderful jolly piano on Bruce’s hits “Hungry Heart” and “Glory Days’. Roy gives those songs a great upbeat feel with his playing. Singer Southside Johnny’s song “It’s Been a Long Time” has three lead vocalists with the other two being Bruce and Bruce’s E Street Band guitarist Steven Van Zandt. Southside Johnny & the Asbury Jukes keyboardist Rusty Cloud provides a good musical base with his piano. Bruce Springsteen wrote, was one of the producers and his E Street Band played on the song “This Little Girl” by Gary U.S. Bonds. Roy’s piano fuses rock & roll and heartland rock sounds. He brings a similar jolly sound to what he brought to the Bruce songs I mentioned. I’ll continue mentioning other artists Roy played for.

Glory Days - Bruce Springsteen (1984)

On the Dire Straits song “Skateaway”, Roy’s piano comes about a minute into the song. Roy alternates between slow playing and fast playing. In the choruses, Roy plays in an epic way with his piano rocking in sync with the drums. Roy is driving the heartland rock sound of this song. In Dire Straits' more popular song “Romeo and Juliet” from the same album, Roy plays melodically. Roy’s strongest moments in the song have a very heartland rock feel. He backs Mark Knopfler’s guitars (which are both acoustic and electric) very well. Michael Stanley did a very good cover of this song. He’s an American heartland rock artist covering a heartland rock song by an English band going back musically to where it came from. The piano by Bob Pelander is more prominent than the original. Some people will hate what I’m about to say. I think it’s better than the original.

Skateaway - Dire Straits (1980)

Even Now is my favourite Bob Seger song. It’s one of his forgotten US hits. Roy’s piano goes up and down the scale in an incredible way. The piano matches greatly with Bob’s vocals with there being sections where Roy’s notes seem to be a musical response to what Bob sang. On “Roll Me Away”, another hit from the same album, Roy gives us majestic rocking piano. Another song Roy played for Bob is “The Fire Inside”, an epic rock song nearly six minutes long. It’s led by the piano and the fact that the guitar part is acoustic gives more room for the piano to rock. Roy’s piano is incredible and detailed which includes two solos.

The Fire Inside - Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band (1991)

On Jackson Browne’s “Here Come Those Tears Again”, Bill Payne plays piano in a warm way. The piano gives off its heartland rock vibes in the way the notes jump from one place to another. Jackson Browne’s epic rock song “The Fuse” has Craig Doerge play incredible heartland rock piano. Craig’s piano has deep dark notes that are so effective. The piano goes very well with David Lindley’s slide guitar. I love how Jackson fuses piano and guitar in a heartland rock setting in many of his songs. Jackson’s classic song “The Pretender” has rich piano from Craig. In parts of the song, the piano shifts from one note to another. 

The Pretender - Jackson Browne (1976)

Running on Empty is a faster rock song driven more by guitar, but Craig’s piano is still a big part of the song. It has an iconic piano opening. Craig incorporates rock & roll influences while maintaining the heartland rock sound. That Girl Could Sing is a case where Jackson played piano on one of his own songs. Jackson’s piano is catchy and has both slower and faster sections. In “For America”, the piano by Jai Winding has sections going back and forth between musical notes. It also has a few short parts led by the piano. Jai’s piano holds this guitar-driven song together very well. Jackson’s lyrics are thought provoking, especially in relation to America’s current issues and 250th anniversary.

That Girl Could Sing - Jackson Browe (1980)

So far these songs by classic rock artists were in the 20th century, with most of them being in the 70s and 80s. I’ll now feature three 21st century songs from classic rock artists. In Michael Stanley’s solo song “My Brand New Day”, Bob Pelander offers amazing, rich piano playing filled with depth. Elton John did a rare case of a heartland rock song in “England and America” ten years ago. Elton showcases his brilliant piano skills by playing different to the way he normally plays where he nails the heartland rock piano sound. Bob Seger’s “Forward Into the Past” is a guitar-driven song, but it’s supported well by Bill Payne’s piano. Bill brings out prominent piano notes in parts of the song which contribute greatly to its rock sound.

My Brand New Day - Michael Stanley (2009)

Companion Articles

I’m providing links to previous articles of mine which are companion articles as they discuss some of the same songs.

Ten Great Jackson Browne Songs by Ten Different Piano Players

Russ Kunkel’s Drumming for Bob Seger

Bill Payne’s Keyboards for Bob Seger

Ten Great Rock Songs Opening Albums

Ten Great Heartland Rock Songs

Six Strong Silver Bullet Band Work for Bob Seger

These songs show the prominent place piano has in heartland rock music. I like the fact that many of them feature a piano/organ combination. They cover a wide range on the rock spectrum going from soft to hard rock. Some of them fuse heartland rock with other styles such as rock & roll and pop rock. Most of the songs are by American artists, but I did include two English artists. They are Dire Straits and Elton John who fuse English rock with American heartland rock in the songs of theirs I featured. Elton’s song is apt for this as it’s literally about England and America. Heartland rock is a genre which has some epic long rock songs like “The Pretender” and “The Fire Inside”. I’d be interested in hearing what you think of the heartland rock piano sound.

Singers & Sidemen Songs

Sidemen are backing musicians who play for singers. They could be members of a singer’s band and/or session musicians. I decided to write an article collecting a set of songs of singers and a song one of their sidemen sing. I paired it so that the sideman played on the singer's song. These pairs are set where the first song is by the singer and the second song is by the sideman. There are even a few cases where the singer appears on the sideman’s song. We’ll start by going back 50 years.

Elton John - (Gotta Get A) Meal Ticket (1975)

I chose this song as Elton John’s “Captain Fantastic” album is celebrating its 50th anniversary this year. I recently listened to the very good Dolby Atmos version of the album on Blu-ray audio. This is a powerful rocker opened by Davey Johnstone’s guitar. Davey plays great guitar throughout. Elton rocks out on his piano and also plays a clavinet which gives quirky keyboard parts. Elton’s vocals are aggressive. The backing vocals of Elton’s band support him well. Davey gives one of his signature sounding guitar solos. Nigel Olsson rocks very well with his powerful drumming. This song shows what a great rock artist Elton John is.

Nigel Olsson - Showdown (1980)

This is a solo song by Elton’s drummer Nigel Olsson. Nigel and Elton’s roles are inverted here as Elton plays piano on this song. Elton’s original bassist Dee Murray is also on this song. Nigel sings soulfully in this rock song and his drumming is powerful. The castanets remind me of those instruments featured on Elton’s rock classic “Funeral for a Friend / Love Lies Bleeding”. There are good synth parts featured in the song. This song has a good early 80s soft rock feel. Elton plays great rock piano especially at the end of the song.

Eric Clapton - Somebody’s Knockin’ (2016)

This is Eric Clapton’s version of an unreleased J.J. Cale song. It has a blues rock feel. Eric rocks out with his guitar in the opening section. Keyboardist Chris Stainton supports the song with his piano. A few minutes into the song, Chris gives a good piano solo. I like how he makes the notes go up and down. Following that, we get a bluesy organ solo by Paul Carrack. Paul’s organ has a good presence in the song following this solo. The song ends with Eric giving a powerful solo. In it, Eric’s guitar matches well with Chris’ piano and Paul interjects good organ parts in.

Ace (Paul Carrack) - How Long (1974)

This is a hit song Paul Carrack had with the band Ace. Paul has worked with Eric in the studio and been a member of his band for some tours. Paul wrote, sang and played keyboards on this song. It’s opened solely by its bass guitar part and Paul’s electric piano part soon joins in. Paul sings in a warm and melodic way. His electric piano matches well with the guitar solo. This is a 70s soft rock classic.

Jackson Browne - For Everyman (1973)

Jackson Browne’s folk rock song features a mix of guitars, piano and organ. The guitar part is mainly acoustic. Jackson and David Lindley both play that instrument, with David also playing electric guitar. Jackson sings in an intimate way. Craig plays a good piano part. The organ played by Jimmy Buffett’s keyboardist Michael Utley adds a lot of colour to the song. David plays a gentle electric guitar part near the end. This is an epic six minute long song.

Craig Doerge - Reno (1973)

This is a song from Craig Doerge’s solo album. Craig did a lot of work with Jackson Browne in the studio and has toured with him. He was part of Jackson’s hit album “Running on Empty” of original songs recorded on the road. Craig plays good rock piano and sings in a deep way. The backing vocals are strong and effective. The guitar comes in and out of the song with its strong parts. The guitar part at the end of the song goes well with Craig’s piano. This is a good mid-tempo rock song.

Michael Stanley - Sound of a Train (2015)

Michael Stanley is an American rock singer from Cleveland. I wish more people around the world knew about his work. This is a song he wrote with his guitarist Marc Lee Shannon. I had previously featured Marc’s version of the song in my article “Ten Train Songs”. This song features acoustic guitar, piano and organ. Michael sings in a warm and powerful way. The piano gives off a relaxing, warm feel and the organ adds to the song. It has an americana rock ballad feel, which reminds me of Bob Seger’s “Against the Wind” album.

Marc Lee Shannon - I’m On It (2006)

Michael produced Marc Lee Shannon’s debut album, which sees them reverse roles. Michael played instruments on the album, and he wrote and provided backing vocals on this song. It opens with a powerful drum beat and gets into this great rock feel. The song features a good mix of guitar, piano and organ. Marc sings in a tough way with passion. His vocals are very effective. Michael’s backing vocals come in which are featured in sections of the song. They support Marc well. I like how Marc and Michael’s voices go together. There’s a creative country influenced guitar solo I’m assuming is by Marc. I like the ad-libbing Marc does towards the end of the song. This is a catchy, melodic country rock song.

Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band - Little Drummer Boy (1987)

As we’re approaching Christmas, it’s fitting to feature a Christmas song. Bob sings this Christmas classic powerfully. Silver Bullet Band keyboardist Craig Frost provides a good piano part which gives a foundation to the song. Saxophonist Alto Reed provides nice sax parts. Alto mentioned that the Silver Bullet Band had recorded often with drummer Don Brewer, yet this is the only officially released studio track with him. Don was a touring drummer on most Silver Bullet Band tours from the 1980s to the 2010s. The guitar parts are played by Rick Vito and Bruce Springsteen guitarist Nils Lofgren. There is a great guitar part that comes throughout the song. It’s great to have a Christmas song given the Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band rock treatment.

Grand Funk Railroad (Don Brewer & Craig Frost) - We’re An American Band (1973) 

This #1 US hit is written and sung by Don Brewer who’s the drummer of Grand Funk Railroad. The song opens with a creative drumming part. Don sings loudly in a passionate way. He drums very well throughout this song, hitting the drums with intensity. The band’s keyboardist Craig Frost plays great electric piano. He does wonderful synth work in the choruses. Don and Craig would both end up working with Bob Seger’s Silver Bullet Band the following decade with Don as a touring musician and Craig an official member. Mark Farner gives a good guitar solo. This rock song is produced by Todd Rundgren.

These singers & sidemen songs feature a diverse range of rock songs. It’s interesting that the opening and closing pairs both feature a sideman song by a singing drummer. The singers in both pairs are my two favourite singers Elton John & Bob Seger. If you enjoyed this article, you might be interested in my previous article “Ten Songs Featuring Elton John Sidemen Vol. 2”.

Ten Fool Songs

I’ve been listening to some songs recently with the word “fool” in the title. That led me thinking it would be a good topic to write an article compiling fool songs. Most of these songs use the term “fool” in relation to relationships, such as someone seeing himself as the fool or viewed that way in the third person. I will only talk about the song’s meaning when they deviate from that trend. I featured two of the songs on this list in my recent article “Magical Music of 1978”. We’ll start by going back 50 years.

Fool’s Gold - Procol Harum (1975)

The song opens with Gary Brooker’s piano and his singing. Other instruments slowly come in and it becomes a full band song quickly. It has an incredible rock energy and features great guitar by Mick Grabham. Gary’s piano rocks well during this song including the way it backs the guitars. The song seems to be about someone who was determined to be successful and failed. Fool’s gold refers to a substance which resembles gold, but is worthless. It also means something incorrectly perceived as very successful. Gary sings about how fool’s gold fooled him. He seems to be singing figuratively. We get some horns close to the end of the song.

Ship of Fools - Bob Seger (1976)

This is a countryish sounding soft rock ballad. The piano isn’t dominant, but provides a good musical base. The creative guitar parts by Drew Abbott come in and out of the song. The accordion has a good presence. Ship of fools is a metaphor by Plato about a ship having an unfit crew which can refer to a dysfunctional democracy. The song is about someone who sailed on a ship with a crew and says what happened. It’s only at the end we find out that the ship sank and he’s the sole survivor. That’s when he refers to it as a “ship of fools”. Bob sings in an intimate manner.

Fool (If You Think It’s Over) - Chris Rea (1978)

The song opens with a light beat. It’s led by an electric piano. Chris Rea’s acoustic piano comes in a bit later which has a good presence in parts of the song. A vibraphone provides some good notes. There is a nice saxophone solo at the halfway point. An orchestra is featured. Producer Gus Dudgeon gives the song a very full production with so many instruments that don’t clash, but support each other. Chris sings this song in a warm way.

What a Fool Believes - The Doobie Brothers (1978)

Michael McDonald wrote this song with Kenny Loggins, sings it and plays piano & synths (with Bill Payne). The piano & synths combine to form a unique keyboard sound. Michael sings powerfully and soulfully. He also sings backing vocals which adds to the song. This is a very melodic song which has a fun, enjoyable feel.

Fool in the Rain - Led Zeppelin (1979)

This is a softer song by Led Zeppelin, though it’s good to have something rockier than the last three songs. John Paul Jones’ piano has a prominent part and opens the song with its riff. John Bonham's drumming is powerful. In the middle of the song, the melody changes with great drumming and percussion. This section brings in a samba sound. It goes back to the piano riff of the start of the song. Jimmy Page plays a creative guitar solo going over it. This solo isn’t intense, but it brings a rock vibe and has jazz influences. Near the end, we get what sounds like acoustic guitar parts. This is an epic six minute rock song.

I’ll Be the Fool Again - Robbie Dupree (1981)

This soft rock song opens with synths and is soon joined by guitar and piano. It’s similar to “What a Fool Believes” we heard earlier, but has more guitars and rock. Robbie sings soulfully. There is a relaxing guitar solo. This song balances synths, piano and guitars well. It’s a good example of yacht rock.

Rope Around a Fool - Elton John (1988)

This piano rock song opens with Elton’s piano and is soon joined by Davey Johnstone’s aggressive guitars. Elton sings powerfully and rocks great on his piano. His piano solo is rock & roll sounding and has good guitar interjections by Davey. This song was the B-Side to his hit “I Don’t Wanna Go On With You Like That” which has a similar piano rock sound.

Any Other Fool - Michael Stanley (2000)

It’s fitting that we follow Elton John as this sounds like an Elton song with its piano ballad style. The line “It never ceases to amaze me” brings to mind Elton’s song “Amazes Me”. Michael’s keyboardist Bob Pelander plays amazing piano and organ. Bob and Michael wrote this song together. Michael sings greatly with emotion. The female backing vocalist supports him well. There is a powerful bridge around the halfway mark followed by a melodic saxophone solo. This song shows what a great singer-songwriter Michael Stanley is. It’s a pity he wasn’t able to be a globally successful singer. He’s someone I recommend listening to.

Fool for Falling In Love - Benny Mardones (2002)

Benny Mardones wrote this song with Roy Orbison. It’s driven by piano and has a strong drum part. The two instruments go together well. There is a subtle organ throughout which adds to the song. Benny sings with passion. At the halfway mark, the piano part brings latin vibes that I like. There is good percussion near the end. Benny gave us a powerful rock ballad with this song.

I Was Fooled - Eric Clapton (2010)

This is a blues cover. The song was written by Jody Williams. Eric brings off blues rock vibes in this song. There is a harmonica throughout it including a good solo. I really like what the piano does during the chorus. Eric sings the blues with passion.

I’ve noticed that a lot of these songs tend to go towards soft rock and ballads with the levels of rock varying. There are some songs which rock harder. I find it interesting that there are only three hit songs which are the ones by The Doobie Brothers, Chris Rea and Led Zeppelin. If you enjoyed reading this, you might be interested in my previous article “Ten Train Songs”. It features many of the same artists.

Ten Train Songs

This article is a collection of ten train songs I chose. I want to clarify that these are not songs by the band Train. They are songs involving trains. Trains are referred to literally, metaphorically or both. All but one of them have the word train in the song title. We’ll start with a song from 55 years ago.

Whisky Train - Procol Harum (1970)

This song is written by guitarist Robin Trower and lyricist Keith Reid. It’s led by the guitars. Lead singer and pianist Gary Brooker’s piano supports Robin’s guitars well. The piano notes going back and forth on a loop are so simple yet so effective. Gary sings aggressively. The lyrics are referring to alcoholism. B.J. Wilson gives great rock drumming. Near the end of the song, we get Robin’s powerful guitar solo. Whisky Train has amazing energy. I love its hard rock sound.

Long Twin Silver Line - Bob Seger (1980)

This rock song is about a train with the lyrics talking about where the train is going. Bob recorded it with the Muscle Shoals Rhythm Section. He sings vigorously. Barry Beckett plays amazing rock and roll piano. Pete Carr has an aggressive guitar solo which Barry supports well. I like how Bob mentions American places in his song which are the cities Chicago, LA, Denver & Salt Lake City and the states Kansas, Nevada & California. This is a fun Bob Seger rocker from the peak of his career.

Keep This Train a-Rollin’ - The Doobie Brothers (1980)

A fun piece of soul influenced soft rock written and sung by Michael McDonald. It opens with organ, then it’s solely Bobby LaKind’s congas which is soon joined by Michael’s piano. Michael's vocals and piano playing are great and energetic. Horns have a good presence including a nice saxophone solo. I love how this song has multiple keyboard parts which include acoustic piano, electric piano, synth, organ and clavinet. Michael seems to be singing about life using a train as a metaphor.

Trains - Al Stewart (1993)

This is an epic eight minute song. Al sings about trains tying it into history and geography. He starts off referring to his experiences growing up in post World War 2 England, discusses 20th century European history and towards the end of the song talks of trains in 1990s America based on his experiences. We get an acoustic guitar solo.There is a great relaxing piano throughout the song. The accordion has a good presence. Al gives us with this song his creative ability to write a melodic ballad dealing with historical topics.

This Train Won’t Stop - Traffic (1994)

This is a melodic mid-tempo rock song from English rock band Traffic’s final album. The final version of Traffic was Steve Winwood and Jim Capaldi, who both wrote this song. Steve plays multiple instruments including piano, organ and guitar. The song is led well by the piano. Steve sings powerfully in his soulful voice and gives a creative guitar solo. It’s good to hear what seems to be a reference to Steve’s solo hit “Higher Love”. Jim provides a good beat with his drums. Steve is singing about life. In the chorus, he sings “this train won’t stop” repeatedly and ends it with “till we reach the end of the line”. The train seems to refer to our lives. I love this kind of piano driven rock.

This Train Don’t Stop There Anymore - Elton John (2001)

Here’s a powerful ballad by Elton John. The instruments are piano, bass, drums and an orchestra arranged by Paul Buckmaster. Elton is using the train metaphor to reflect and look back on his career. Matt Chamberlain drums intensely in a modern way. We get the feel of ballads pre-dating Elton’s music with this song. There is a powerful moment where one of the choruses goes to just Elton & his piano which is soon joined by the other instruments. I like how the backing vocalists sing “don’t stop”.

From a Train - Michael Stanley (2003)

This is a piano ballad somewhat similar to the previous song. The song seems to be about a man who watched a lady he was in love with go away on a train. The train setting is used to explore their relationship issues. Michael’s long-time keyboardist Bob Pelander’s piano gives a relaxing atmosphere. There is a subtle acoustic guitar and synth strings which comes in and out of the song. Michael sings warmly in an intimate way. I like the reference to “Spanish Nights” which must be referring to Michael’s previous song “Spanish Nights” from the Michael Stanley Band. Halfway through the song, gentle drums come in which add a new dimension to the song.

The Train Don’t Stop Here Anymore - Benny Mardones (2006)

I think that this song was influenced or is a response to Elton’s song on this list. Both songs are piano ballads looking back to the past of their careers. Benny sings “I used to be the man” and Elton sings “I used to be the main express”. Benny sings powerfully. This song is led by a mix of electric and acoustic pianos. We hear some other keyboards. Benny sings about his lover he’s no longer with who he misses. I wonder if “the train don’t stop here anymore” is his way of expressing his sadness that they’re no longer together. In the last quarter of the song, there is a train sound which is nice to hear.

Train To Nowhere - Eric Clapton, Mark Knopfler & Don White (2014)

This song was written by J.J. Cale is from Eric Clapton & Friends’ tribute album to J.J. Cale. Mark sings the first two verses, Don sings the third and they sing the fourth one together. Eric sings the choruses. It’s creative how this song uses the voices of three very different singers. Both Eric and Mark play good guitar parts. The song is underpinned well by piano. J.J. seems to be writing about life with the train to nowhere metaphor. This song is a relaxing mid-tempo americana themed rock song.

Sound of a Train - Marc Lee Shannon (2018)

I get similar musical vibes from the previous song. Marc was the guitarist to Michael Stanley featured above. Marc and Michael wrote this song together with Michael’s version released first in 2015. The song opens with drums, Marc sings with guitar coming in and out of the song. Piano follows in a similar fashion to the guitar and it soon has a full band sound. Marc sings with passion. Marc is singing about his lover that he misses. The chorus mentions both the sound of a train and the sound of her voice. This song has a good mix of piano, acoustic and electric guitars.

That was my selection of train songs. There are some common lyrical themes among them. I like how these songs are musically diverse ranging from slow ballads to hard rock.