Saturday 23 March 2024

Bill Payne's Keyboards for Bob Seger

Bob Seger has worked with keyboardist Bill Payne from 1978 onwards. Session musician Bill Payne is part of the southern rock band Little Feat. Bill first worked with Bob playing piano & organ on his 1978 hit “Hollywood Nights” from the “Stranger in Town” album. Bill’s keyboards are just organ at the start. During the first verse, he brings in his piano which adds depth to the song. The piano rocks well with some notable moments. A few years later Bill played all the keyboards (piano, organ & synth) on the ballad “You’ll Accomp’ny Me” from the “Against the Wind” album. This song opens with acoustic guitar and Bill soon brings in his piano & organ. His synth is hard to hear. The piano makes this song whole and there are strong organ moments. In both songs, Bill played with Bob who was the sole guitarist.

Hollywood Nights (1978)


You’ll Accomp’ny Me (1980)


On the next album “The Distance”, two songs Bill played piano include the country hit “Shame on the Moon” and the ballad “Love’s the Last to Know”. On the Rodney Crowell cover “Shame On the Moon”, the sole keyboards at the start are organ. After the first chorus, Bill brings in a memorable piano solo with piano continuing throughout the song. Bill’s piano elevates “Shame On the Moon”. Piano is the main instrument on the ballad “Love’s the Last to Know” giving Bill a stronger presence than the previous songs. He plays gently and melodically giving the power of a piano ballad. In these three songs, he played with Silver Bullet Band keyboardist Craig Frost on organ and would do the same on the songs in the next paragraph.


Bill played keyboards (piano & synth) on most tracks on the 1986 “Like a Rock” album. This is the most prominent presence he’s had on a Bob Seger album. I will describe what I consider to be his best contribution from that album. In the heartland rocker “American Storm”, his piano is driving the song. In the rock ballad title track, he was playing gently and supported Rick Vito’s slide guitar solos well. In the intense rock song “Sometimes”, he played a good supporting role and provided a memorable piano solo.


American Storm (1986)



This album also has songs with the combination of him on piano and Craig Frost on synth. The two keyboards went well together on “The Aftermath” with Bill rocking out well. The two instruments were used in a different way on the ballad “Somewhere Tonight”. Somewhere Tonight has gentle sections driven by Bill’s piano and rockier sections driven by Rick Vito’s guitar. On the following 1991 album “The Fire Inside”, he played on two Tom Waits covers. One of them was the jazz song “New Coat of Paint” which brings a completely different sound to what Bob normally does. Bill does incredible piano playing including having two piano solos. The other one was the country song “Blind Love” with his prominent gentle country playing.


We’re now going back to a Bob Seger original. Bill played piano on the 2006 rock ballad “Wait for Me” which is a very Bob Seger song. Bill gives warm melodic playing. He backed Bob Seger’s guitar solo. I didn't like how the “Face the Promise” album this song is from had a lack of keyboards on it. I wanted there to be more piano on the album. I wish Bill could have played on more tracks. His presence would have elevated the material like how he did on “Hollywood Nights” as that song was recorded as a band without the keyboards first. I’m imagining how great the title track could have sounded with Bill’s piano & organ.


Wait for Me (2006)


On Bob’s last album “I Knew You When” in 2017, Bill played on three songs. The “I Knew You When” songs featured unreleased songs, most of which had been updated as well as a few covers and newly written songs. These songs Bill played on were from the unreleased “Blue Ridge” album recorded in the late 1990s. On the piano ballad “I Knew You When”, Bill plays in a relaxed, gentle way. In aggressive rocker “Forward Into the Past”, Bill plays a supporting role. He gives good rock piano moments throughout the song. The song “Blue Ridge” opens with real drums and steel drums. I suspect these steel drums are played by Craig Frost on keyboards as I didn’t see any steel drums in the credits. Soon, Bill’s piano appears. It gives a good presence in this melodic rocker. Bill accompanies Bob on his rocking guitar solo.


Blue Ridge (2017)


These songs showcase Bill Payne’s contributions to Bob Seger’s work. He is one of the key session musicians Bob has worked with over the years. Bill contributed to the iconic Bob Seger sound and brought vibes from americana & southern rock. The Bob Seger songs he played on are rockers & ballads and also other genres like country & jazz. Bill showed the power of the piano as a rock instrument. I hope to see Bill Payne reunited on the next Bob Seger album.

2 comments:

  1. Hi Asela,

    I will comment on this post by giving each song a rating and a short review. I hope you approve of this.

    Hollywood Nights - 3.5/5 - Classic Seger. A song that might be used in the background of a montage of a movie about a road trip across America.

    Accomp'ny Me - 4.5/5 - Classic Seger.

    Love's The Last To Know - 3/5 - A sad song but good piano and drums.

    Shame On The Moon - 4/5 - Classic Seger.

    Blind Love - 3/5 - Average.

    American Storm - 3/5 - Typical '80s song. Average.

    Like A Rock - 4/5 - Kind of sad although the title implies it would cheer me up.

    Sometimes - 4.5/5 - Typical '80s song. Happier.

    New Coat Of Paint - 3.5/5 - Blues. Much like Robert Johnson, Eric Clapton or J.J. Cale.

    Somewhere Tonight - 3.5/5 - Average.

    The Aftermath - 4/5 - Typical '80s. Motivational.

    Wait For Me - 4/5 - Above Average.

    Blue Ridge - 3/5 - Average.

    Forward Into The Past - 3/5 - Average.

    I Knew You When - 3/5 - Average.

    Sadly there are no songs that deserved a rating of 5/5. This would mean that I would listen to it over and over again on repeat.
    Just out of curiosity, which is your favourite decade of Bob Seger songs and has he ever collaborated with a female artist?

    I realise I joined your blog rather late and haven't reviewed other posts in the past. My apologies.

    Regards,

    Devinka

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks very much Devinka for your comment and for giving your thoughts on each of the songs. Interestingly, the three songs you consider "Classic Seger" are big hits of his. I really like what you say about "Hollywood Nights". My favourite decade of Bob Seger songs is the 1970s. Yes, Bob Seger has collaborated with a female artist. He duetted with country singers Martina McBride in 1998 and Patty Loveless in 2006. I really like the Martina McBride duet "Chances Are", https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=V65X-0eK_Do.

      Delete