Showing posts with label Classic Rock. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Classic Rock. Show all posts

Wednesday, 11 November 2026

Albums I'd Like to See Elton John Record

As an Elton John fan, I decided to write a list of albums I’d like to see Elton John record. These are types of albums he hasn’t recorded yet. However, he has recorded at least one song in the style of my proposed album. I embed the audio of an Elton John song to display the kind of musical sound this proposed album could have. Let’s start.


Jazz Rock Album

Elton has done some songs over the years in jazz and jazz rock styles. My idea for this album would be dominated by jazz rock songs of different tempos with the remainder being plain jazz songs. It would be a creative challenge for Elton to write rock that’s merged with jazz. He’d be able to bring something new to jazz rock through his songwriting skills. Toto would be an influence for this album. I understand they were one of Elton’s favourite bands during their peak. He’s worked with Toto members David Paich (keyboards), Steve Lukather (guitar), Steve Porcaro (keyboards), Jeff Porcaro (drums) and Greg Phillinganes (keyboards). Jeff played all the drums on Elton’s 1982 “Jump Up” album which was the same year of Toto’s massive success with “Toto IV”.


Other influences I envision are Steely Dan and Chicago, specifically the “Chicago X” album. In my article “Ten Great Rock Songs Opening Albums”, I included the song “Once or Twice” from “Chicago X”. I said “I like Robert Lamm’s rock and roll piano. It’s creative to feature that kind of piano playing in a jazz rock song.” Elton similarly would bring his signature rock & roll piano sound in a jazz rock setting on some songs. The Elton John song I’m featuring below is “Out of the Blue”, an instrumental jazz rock song that came out 50 years ago. Elton does great improvisational piano soloing near the end.


Out of the Blue (1976)


Southern Rock Album

Southern rock is similar to rock & roll which is a part of Elton’s music where he has played rock & roll piano on some songs. A southern rock album would give Elton an opportunity to play more rock & roll piano on an album which is something I’d love to see. This album would be influenced by the southern rock band Little Feat who are an influence of Elton’s. A Little Feat style southern rock album would be both musically adjacent to Elton’s music and so different to what he normally does. Elton considers their keyboardist Bill Payne to be one of the best keyboardists he ever heard. Elton would bring in elements of Bill Payne’s piano playing while keeping it focused on Elton’s signature style.


This album would parallel Elton John’s early album “Tumbleweed Connection” (1970). On that album, Elton John and his lyricist Bernie Taupin were influenced by The Band. This album would be influenced by Little Feat in the same fashion. Little Feat’s music is tied to americana, which Elton often goes into on his albums, making a musical continuation of Elton’s work he can use for this album. Elton can also feature traditional Elton John ballads with epic Little Feat style arrangements. I like Little Feat’s latest album “Strike Up the Band” (2025). That would be a good album for Elton to look to for inspiration. It features uptempo songs about enjoying life which is what Elton’s interested in writing at this stage of his career. I’m featuring Elton’s Little Feat sounding song “In the Name of You” below.


In the Name of You (2016)


Heartland Rock Album

This is an Elton John heartland rock album influenced by Bob Seger, Jackson Browne and Michael Stanley. Heartland rock is the most different style of music to Elton’s I’ve featured so far. I’d say he’s done only one heartland rock song in his career. Elton would be creatively challenging himself making a heartland rock album while also taking the genre into new territory by bringing his songwriting, piano and singing brilliance. I’m also a big fan of Bob Seger. It would be epic to imagine Elton doing a song like Bob Seger’s “The Fire Inside”. That song features incredible piano by Roy Bittan including two solos. Bob’s albums do include Elton style ballads and rock & roll songs alongside the fully fledged heartland rock songs, so Elton would have an opportunity to include his traditional ballads and rock & roll songs. Interestingly, Bob has a piano ballad “Love’s the Last to Know” featuring Little Feat keyboardist Bill Payne on piano and Elton’s guitarist Davey Johnstone on acoustic guitar.


My understanding is Jackson Browne is an influence of Elton’s. Elton played piano on Jackson’s song “Red Neck Friend”. It would be incredible hearing an Elton John song in the vein of Jackson Browne’s “The Pretender”. Michael Stanley is an American singer from Cleveland who failed to make it big outside of his state. He is a brilliant rock singer-songwriter who the World needs to hear. He features piano in a lot of his work. Before he went into heartland rock, his folk rock album “Friends & Legends” (1973) reminds me of the early Elton albums “Tumbleweed Connection” (1970) and “Honky Château” (1972). The album’s bassist Kenny Passarelli would join Elton’s band in a few years. An Elton heartland rock album would be similar to how Elton approached his album “Peachtree Road” (2004). That album goes in an americana and country direction sounding different by having a more American sound than what Elton normally does. Elton mixed americana with his brand of pop rock on “Peachtree Road” and would do the same with heartland rock. For Elton’s heartland rock song, I”m featuring “England and America”. I included it and songs by the three heartland rock singers in my my article “Ten Great Heartland Rock Songs”.


England and America (2016)


Piano-Guitar-Bass-Drums Album

This is the most traditional sounding Elton John album on this list. This is a stripped down album with just piano, guitar, bass and drums. When Elton John’s long-time guitarist Davey Johnstone joined his band, the Elton John Band consisted of piano, guitar, bass and drums. Davey was with Nigel Olsson (drums) and the late Dee Murray (bass). Even though Elton had this band, it was rare for Elton to have a song on a studio album with only these four instruments as there was usually something additional such as percussion, additional keyboards, orchestra and/or horns. This album would be only piano, guitar, bass, drums and backing vocals with no additional keyboards, percussion, orchestra and horns.


This album would have rock energy giving both the piano and guitar more room to rock. Davey & Nigel would showcase their great playing which is crucial to the Elton John sound. Elton could do rock & roll, hard rock, blues rock and pop rock. This arrangement would also provide energy and a full band sound to the ballads. The song I’m providing below is the original version of Elton’s rock ballad “Candle in the Wind” which has just these four instruments. Elton leads the song with his piano and Davey plays both acoustic and electric guitars with his electric guitar providing a great rock feel. Elton’s band members provide great backing vocals.


Candle in the Wind (1973)


These are a list of albums I’d like to see Elton John record. They comprise three sub-genres of rock he hasn’t done a whole album before as well as an album with a different recording arrangement. I’d be interested to hear if you have thoughts on what I said or albums you’d like to see Elton record.

Thursday, 22 October 2026

Ten Songs Featuring Bob Seger Band Members

I decided to write an article of ten songs featuring Bob Seger band members. Every song features someone who backed Bob Seger. A wide variety of artists are featured with one Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band song included. Bob Seger’s popular backing band the Silver Bullet Band was formed in the 1970s. Unfortunately, most of the songs on this list don’t feature official Silver Bullet Band members as non-Bob Seger song options with them are limited. Most of the band members featured are touring musicians who complemented the Silver Bullet Band. I also included some band members from the pre-Silver Bullet Band era. I mention the band member/s after the year of the song unless they’re one of the artists. I had previously written a similar article “Ten Songs Featuring Elton John Sidemen” where I included a Bob Seger song.

Walk Like a Man (You Can Call Me Your Man) - Grand Funk Railroad (1973) - Craig Frost & Don Brewer


The song opens with an electric piano. Keyboardist Craig Frost would later join the Silver Bullet Band and drummer Don Brewer would become a touring drummer for Bob Seger. Craig’s electric piano gives a strong driving rock presence which goes well with the guitars. He also plays a subtle organ part which adds to the song. Don Brewer wrote this song with bandmember Mark Farner and Don sings it. Mark’s guitar solo is very good. I like how Don hits the drums hard in a very effective way. This song has similarities to Bob Seger’s electric piano rocker “Black Night”.


Double Dealin’ Four Flusher - The Doobie Brothers (1975) - Bill Payne


This song is written by Patrick Simmons. It’s opened by a special drum pattern. Patrick shares the lead vocals on this with Tom Johnston and drummer Keith Knudsen. I like the use of three lead vocalists. This song has an aggressive rock feel with strong guitars. Bill Payne gives a great keyboard presence with both electric and acoustic piano. His acoustic piano gives off amazing rock & roll vibes. There’s an intense rocking guitar solo with both horn and piano interjections followed by a brief slow section of the song driven by the electric piano. This song is similar to Bob Seger’s version of Frankie Miller’s “Ain’t Got No Money”. Both songs are guitar-driven hard rock songs with a rock & roll piano.


Rock and Roll Never Forgets - Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band (1976)


It’s the opening track of Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band’s “Night Moves” album that came out 50 years ago today on the 22nd of October 1976. This version of the Silver Bullet Band consists of Drew Abbott (lead guitar), Chris Campbell (bass), Alto Reed (saxophone), Robyn Robins (keyboards) and Charlie Allen Martin (drums). Robyn’s piano underpins the song and his organ flourishes add to it. Alto’s sax in this song is a key element of the Silver Bullet Band sound. Drew gives a blues inspired guitar solo. Bob gives his signature rock singing. I like his vocal ad-libbing in the last section of the song. Horns have a good presence at the end and go back and forth with Drew’s guitar.


Next Time You See Her - Eric Clapton (1977) - Dick Sims & Jamie Oldaker


This ballad has both a soft rock and americana feel. Eric Clapton’s band members at the time included Dick Sims (keyboards), Jamie Oldaker (drums) and Marcy Levy (backing vocals) who were with Bob Seger earlier in the 1970s. Marcy does not seem to be on this track though. Eric sings in a warm, intimate way. There is nice electric guitar playing by Eric and/or George Terry. Dick’s piano & organ playing is wonderfully melodic and very prominent. Jamie gives energy with his drumming. I love his clear, sharp drum sound. I see similarities between this song and Bob Seger’s “You’ll Accomp’ny Me” in both songs' piano & organ parts and being warm ballads.


Tender Is the Night by Jackson Browne (1983) - Rick Vito


The song opens mainly with Jackson’s vocals and Craig Doerge’s electric piano. There is light drumming and other keyboards appear. The guitars then come in aggressively. Rick Vito’s lead guitar playing is creative as he plays both understated and intense in different sections. Jackson sings tenderly throughout most of the song. Rick’s guitar solo is loud and fast. Doug Haywood’s organ has a good presence. This song has musical similarities with Bob Seger’s “The Long Way Home”. While Bob’s song is slower as a ballad, both of them are soft rock songs with electric piano and a Rick Vito guitar solo.


Dyin’ Ain't Much of a Livin’ - Jon Bon Jovi (1990) - Kenny Aronoff


It’s a solo song by Jon Bon Jovi, lead vocalist of Bon Jovi. Jon sings intimately in the verses and powerfully in an epic arena rock voice in the choruses. Kenny gives powerful rock drumming. Elton John plays wonderful piano and sings backing vocals. Elton’s piano is mixed in well and he gives his strength as a rock pianist. One of the guitarists on this song is Jeff Beck. The guitars give a great, intense rock sound. This song is similar to Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band’s “Sunburst” as both have a combination of piano balladry and hard rock guitar.


Ain't Nothing Like the Real Thing - Marcella Detroit & Elton John (1994)


This is a cover which was originally sung by Marvin Gaye and Tammi Terrell. Marcella Detroit is the backing vocalist Marcy Levy I mentioned earlier who was in both Eric Clapton’s and Bob Seger’s bands.This version from Marcella’s album, unlike the one on Elton’s album has an intro with Marcella singing. It soon goes into Elton & Marcella singing who sound great together. Both of them sing very soulfully. This recording isn’t great music as its production is dated. What makes it worthwhile is the positive, enjoyable vibes and Elton’s great singing. There’s a harmonica which has a good presence. It was a minor hit in the UK. This song brings to mind “Chances Are”, Bob Seger’s duet with Martina McBride. Both are 1990s duets of male classic rockers singing with a female singer in a different genre to their own. Elton’s duet is soul and Bob’s duet is country.


Mama’s Little Baby - Delbert McClinton & Dick50 (2009) - Rob McNelley


This song is an example of Delbert McClinton’s signature blues rock sound. Delbert recorded this with the backing band Dick50. It opens with strong drumming. Rob McNelley’s aggressive guitars sound great. He would soon become Bob Seger’s lead guitarist. The piano part is very energetic and lively. Delbert sings great in a loud, strong way. The backing vocals support Delbert well. This is a fun uptempo song. It’s a bit like Bob Seger’s “No Matter Who You Are”. While Bob’s song rocks harder without a blues component, both songs have similar energy and backing vocals.


Rag Top Down - Little Feat (2012) - Bill Payne & Fred Tackett


Keyboardist Bill Payne wrote this song with lyricist Robert Hunter and sings it. It’s a midtempo southern rock song. Bill’s keyboard playing is great. He gives us both americana-driven rock piano and organ. The guitars play a good supporting role. Fred Tackett who was part of a Bob Seger tour with Bill is one of the guitarists. The song seems to end and then it brings great keyboard and guitar rock jamming. This song feels like a mix of Bob Seger’s ballad “No Man’s Land” and uptempo song “Brave Strangers”. Its tempo is in between the two with the feel of “No Man’s Land” and a piano part in the direction of “Brave Strangers”.


Little Bitty Soul by Andy Pratt (2013) - Kenny Aronoff


This is a ballad giving optimism in response to the troubles of the world. The keyboards seem to be a combination of electric & acoustic piano. Andy Pratt plays multiple instruments on this song including piano. His singing conveys the emotions of someone weary and struggling. Kenny supports the song well with his drumming. He gives energy to his playing while also keeping them understated to suit the sound of this ballad. A flute appears at times which gives a good presence. We get a bit of rock guitar towards the end of the song which is a welcome addition. Bob Seger has done songs like this such as his 2006 unreleased song “Let Me Try” which was unveiled last month. Bob’s song has musical and lyrical similarities with Andy’s song.


This is a collection of songs covering a 40 year period from 1973 to 2013. I liked selecting a group of different songs through the lens of my Bob Seger fandom. These songs have a rock energy which is something Bob Seger has. We get fully fledged rockers and ballads. Most of the ballads have rock elements too. These band members did a great job supporting both Bob Seger and the artists featured on this list. Relating to the Bob Seger band members, some session musicians were featured on these songs who Bob has recorded with. They include Bob Glaub, Russ Kunkel and Sam Clayton. Backing vocalists Julia Waters and Maxine Waters also apply. Those who back singers and bands with instruments and/or backing vocals deserve credit as the songs wouldn’t be as great without their contribution.

Saturday, 15 August 2026

Ten Songs Produced by Barry Beckett

This article is my first collection of songs by a music producer. The producer I’m featuring is Barry Beckett. He’s a keyboardist who was part of a group of session musicians known as the Muscle Shoals Rhythm Section. They worked with singer Bob Seger who I’m a fan of. In most of the songs I selected, Barry shared production credit with others. Barry played piano on some of the songs he produced. Sometimes albums Barry produced did not specify which tracks he played on. Therefore, I only mention Barry’s piano playing if I could verify that he played on the song. The songs cover a 20 year period beginning in 1973.

Turn Out the Light - Orleans (1973)


Barry produced the album with Muscle Shoals Rhythm Section drummer Roger Hawkins and plays piano. Barry’s piano opens the song and dominates. His playing is powerful. The start of the song is John Hall’s singing who also plays the guitar. We get a bit of guitar and backing vocals. After a while it becomes a full band song. This soft rock ballad has gospel influences. John gives a nice guitar solo followed by Barry’s powerful piano solo. This song is produced wonderfully as it’s clear sounding. It’s able to be both intimate in its sections dominated by piano and epic when it has the full band sound. It uses the full band to give power and energy to this ballad.


Smoke from a Distant Fire - Sanford-Townsend Band (1977)


The Sanford-Townsend Band consisted of Ed Sanford and John Townsend. They are both singer-keyboardists. This is a pop rock song with a southern rock feel. Barry produced this song with Jerry Wexler which is also the case for the next song. This song was a hit in the US. There is a warm saxophone part. John’s singing is soulful. Ed supports John with his good backing vocals. There are many elements in this song, acoustic piano, electric piano, electric guitar, organ and saxophone which the production balances very well. Sections of the song are driven by the electric piano while others are driven by the acoustic piano. There are two relaxing solos, one guitar and the other saxophone. This song has a good jolly feel.


Communiqué - Dire Straits (1979)


Dire Straits leader Mark Knopfler wrote, sang and played lead guitar on this song. It opens with Mark’s guitar playing with it soon joined by Barry’s piano playing. Some of the notes Barry plays reminds me of his piano part in Bob Seger’s “Sunspot Baby”. His playing goes well with Dire Straits. Mark’s provides creative guitar playing. The production brings in southern American sensibilities to a uniquely English rock band. This is an epic rock song over five minutes long.


Paris - Southside Johnny & The Asbury Jukes (1979)


This is the first song on the list Barry produced by himself. Kevin Kavanaugh’s piano playing is powerful. Southside Johnny sings with passion. Horns are featured in parts of the song. There is a relaxing saxophone solo. Kevin’s organ plays a good supporting role. Barry’s production is true to Southside Johnny & The Asbury Jukes’ brand of rock as it features both heartland rock and soul sounds.


Lucretia - Levon Helm (1982)


Barry produced this song with Muscle Shoals Rhythm Section guitarist Jimmy Johnson. This is a solo song by Levon Helm who was in The Band. Levon sings powerfully. His singing of the line “hey Mister can you tell me where to go” reminds me of similar lines he sang in The Band’s song “The Weight”. The piano underpins this americana sounding rock song. The guitars bring in both country and rock vibes. The production does a good job of balancing the guitars and the piano.


I Got Love - Glenn Frey (1984)


This is a solo song by Glenn Frey who was in The Eagles. I’d classify it as soft rock with soul elements. Barry produced this song with Glenn & Allan Blazek and plays all the keyboards on it. The song opens with mainly Glenn’s singing, Barry’s piano and light drumming. Soon, the drumming gets more intense with all the instruments appearing. Barry plays some organ notes which make appearances during the chorus. Glenn sings very well. You can hear his emotion. The horns contribute greatly to the song. Barry plays a few rock & roll piano notes near the end. The production feels epic giving different instruments their moments throughout the song.


Southern Star - Alabama (1989)


Barry plays piano on this country song and produced it with the Alabama band. Southern Star has multiple instruments: piano, organ, acoustic and electric guitars. Lead singer Randy Owen sings very well. The band provides good backing vocals. There are some rock elements as Barry’s piano seems to give brief rock & roll sounds and the guitar solos sound a little rockish. The production feels epic with its full band country sound.


Go On - Delbert McClinton (1990)


Barry and Delbert McClinton produced this song. This song is in Delbert’s style which mixes country, blues and rock. There are two bluesy guitar solos. The piano provides a good base for the song. There are moments where the piano does some additional notes. The horns provide a good presence. The production gives a relaxed uptempo feel.

 

Always in My Heart - Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band (1991)


This rock ballad Barry produced with Bob Seger. It came out 35 years ago in August 1991. The piano is played by Bob’s classic rock peer Bruce Hornsby. The opening section is dominated by Bob’s singing and Bruce’s piano. They pair well together. This song is an example of a great Bob Seger ballad. Bruce’s piano playing is epic. Bob sings incredibly. The production showcases the power of a Bob Seger ballad. It mixes this piano led song with its guitar and keyboard parts.


A Woman’s Needs - Elton John & Tammy Wynette (1993)


Barry produced this duet between Elton John and country singer Tammy Wynette. Elton wrote this country song with his lyricist Bernie Taupin. Tammy sings at the start. She sings well in her southern accent. Elton sings after that and comes with very powerful singing. Their singing styles are totally different yet work so well. They sing in conversation in the chorus. There are similarities in this song and the preceding one. Both are ballads featuring the musicians Don Potter (acoustic guitar), Dan Huff (electric guitar), Michael Rhodes (bass) and Eddie Bayers (drums). The difference is the country genre of “A Woman’s Needs”. Elton brings his signature brilliant piano playing in a country setting. Barry’s good production brings the guitars in and out of this Elton John piano ballad. He deserves credit for bringing a strong collaboration between an English rock singer and an American country singer.


Barry’s productions have an organic clear sound. He gives an important place for the piano whether it's his playing or someone else’s. Barry balances the different instruments well. He brings in southern sounds like country and blues into songs produced by rock artists. He did work in the country genre which I included. As I’m a classic rock fan, most of the artists I featured are rock artists. It’s interesting to note that the last four songs feature the rhythm section of drummer Eddie Bayers and bassist Michael Rhodes. Barry Beckett is a great producer and keyboardist who made a great contribution to popular music.

Thursday, 23 July 2026

AI Bizarrely Got My Blog Wrong


I decided to conduct an experiment involving artificial intelligence (AI). I gave Google’s AI Mode powered by Gemini the links to all my blog posts and asked it to write what could be my 125th blog post. I requested it to be under 1000 words and use British spelling. This is an experiment I wanted to do for some time. Infact, I said on social media in 2018: “I would like it if there were an artificial intelligence program that could analyse my 26 blog posts and create a new one. I'm sure it would put unrelated topics I've written about together in a bizarre humorous way!” AI did put unrelated topics together and bizarrely got my blog wrong. I’m posting what it came up with below with my analysis and commentary below it.

“The S Synergy: When Heartland Rock Meets Star Trek Style Sci-Fi

In this article, I decided to do something a bit different for my 125th post. Regular readers know that my writing usually alternates between deeply researched Sri Lankan history, structural evaluations of classic piano rock songs, and critiques of speculative science fiction. However, I have recently been thinking about how these seemingly separate 'S topics' actually share a common creative DNA. Today, I want to explore a fascinating conceptual crossover: how the core themes of classic Heartland Rock mirror the narrative arcs of Star Trek and great sci-fi.

It might sound like an unusual pairing at first. Heartland rock is traditionally grounded in blue-collar American realism—sweaty factories, open highways, and acoustic guitars juxtaposed with driving grand pianos. Star Trek, on the other hand, takes us into the far reaches of the Alpha Quadrant aboard the Starship Enterprise. Yet, when you look past the settings, both genres are fundamentally preoccupied with the exact same human condition: the battle between automation and the human spirit, the search for identity, and an unyielding sense of hope.

The Fight Against Automation: Seger and the Borg

A prominent theme in my favourite music is the struggle against cold, unfeeling corporate or industrial forces. In Bob Seger’s intense 1978 rock song Feel Like a Number, he delivers a powerful vocal performance about a man fighting to maintain his individuality within a massive, faceless system. Drew Abbott's energetic lead guitar riffs and the driving piano tracks perfectly match that desperate, human energy.

Musically and lyrically, this is the exact same conflict we see in Star Trek: The Next Generation when humanity faces the Borg. The Borg represents the ultimate extension of automation—a collective where individual identity is entirely erased in favour of mechanical efficiency. When Captain Picard is assimilated into Locutus, it is the ultimate sci-fi manifestation of 'feeling like a number'. Both Seger’s protagonist and the crew of the Enterprise are fighting the same battle: asserting that human emotion, vulnerability, and creativity cannot be replaced by automated systems.

The Piano as the Sci-Fi Instrument of Empathy

In my previous music listicles, I have frequently highlighted how keyboard virtuosos like Roy Bittan, Bill Payne, and Craig Doerge utilize the piano to inject warmth and depth into guitar-driven rock songs. In heartland rock, the piano is often the emotional anchor. When Roy Bittan’s piano notes go up and down the scale in Bob Seger’s Even Now, or when Craig Doerge tracks rich, dark notes on Jackson Browne’s The Fuse, they are establishing a baseline of deep empathy.

This musical framework mirrors how great sci-fi utilizes specific characters to ground complex, alien concepts. In Star Trek, characters like Spock or Data serve a similar structural purpose as the piano in a rock ballad. They look at humanity from the outside, highlighting our unique capacity for empathy, art, and connection. Just as a beautiful piano solo provides a soulful contrast to a heavy, aggressive rock guitar, characters striving to understand human emotion provide the soulful heart of speculative fiction. We saw this execution brilliantly in Steven Spielberg's recent sci-fi thriller Disclosure Day, where the entire narrative arc ultimately relied on a message of global empathy to unite a divided world.

The Optimistic Journey

Ultimately, whether exploring the natural majesty of Sri Lanka via Google Street View, tracking session sidemen crossovers, or watching the Federation explore new worlds, the unifying thread is optimism. Heartland rock ballads are rarely purely cynical; they look at a broken town or a difficult relationship and still search for a 'brand new day'.

Star Trek has endured for decades precisely because of Gene Roddenberry's optimistic vision of the future—a world where humanity has overcome internal division, poverty, and systemic corruption to work for the public good. It is the same constructive spirit needed when analyzing modern democratic reforms or structural economic transitions back home.

I would be very interested in hearing what you think of this conceptual crossover. Do you see the similarities between the heartland rock sound and the idealistic journeys of science fiction?”

This is a blog post I would never write. Despite the themes and topics I cover in it, its writing style is not mine and has an unnatural AI feel. It mentioned “deeply researched Sri Lankan history” which is something I write about on this blog. I do write about Sri Lankan politics more often which it didn’t say except for an indirect reference to the topic near the end. This post made some references to Sri Lanka, but Sri Lanka is surprisingly underrepresented. It takes a lot of material from what I wrote recently.


The heartland rock comparison to Star Trek is an interesting one. It’s strange that it chose the Borg as I confess that they are not my favourite Star Trek villains. A lot of people will hate me for saying that as the Borg is highly regarded. They first appeared on “Star Trek:  The Next Generation” (TNG). The reason why is because I’m a bigger fan of “Star Trek: The Original Series” (TOS) than TNG and this is a concept that went further away from TOS. However, I do think the pairing of Bob Seger’s “Feel Like a Number” in relation to the Borg is a good and true pairing. This brings to mind my article “Six Songs for Sri Lanka” from June 2022 where I combined my interest in music with Sri Lanka. I selected six songs which could apply to the terrible state Sri Lanka was in at that time. One of them was Bob Seger’s “Feel Like a Number”.


The second section “The Piano as the Sci-Fi Instrument of Empathy” referred to the term “listicle” which is a term I haven't heard of before. That’s referring to my blog articles in list form. I’ve written listicles featuring a set of songs. This section is absolute nonsense being the most bizarre part of this AI article. It’s silly calling pianos a sci-fi instrument of empathy. Spock and Data in Star Trek are not like the piano in a rock ballad.


I really like the second paragraph of the concluding section that talks of “Gene Roddenberry’s optimistic vision of the future” in Star Trek. That is something that is needed in the world right now. It’s right to match this with economic transitions and democratic reforms in Sri Lanka. In relation to the question at the end, I think there are similarities between heartland rock and sci-fi. I pointed out areas where the comparison worked for me. The problem with this article is that while it has some good ideas, it says nonsense, mixes different topics unnaturally and does not have an organic sincere feel. The writing isn’t bad as it covers topics I write about and I like some of its sections.


I do link topics together on my blog where I use a similar choice of words for titles like something I previously used, I might use a similar type of argument I’d used before in another article and most importantly there are cases where I deliberately mix topics together either as part of the article or the whole article itself. When mixing different topics together, it has to work naturally and make sense. It can’t be just mixed directly which would make it a bad article. There are some mixed topics I hope to cover in future articles.


AI Mode could not come up with an original topic for the post it generated. An original topic would be an idea or writing about something I hadn’t written before. It reused topics and points I’d said before in my blog. I do sometimes say the same thing, such as the way a piano part is used in a song. I don’t give them excessively like AI Mode did. The part linking Bob Seger to Star Trek’s Borg is original.


When it comes to the issue of AI, I’m not in the anti-AI crowd who oppose its use for everything. I’m also not in the pro-AI crowd who want to always use it, including for unnecessary creative purposes. AI is a useful tool and I think a healthy balance is needed. I use AI Mode. It can get fun when I feed it ideas to discuss films I’d like to see. I ask it questions and it gives answers. Some of the answers are valid and true. Others are invalid and not true.


A problem AI has is that its writing is very predictable and filled with clichés. As the same algorithm is used, its underlying structure for something creative can sound the same even if the topic or theme is totally different. The saying “Don’t believe everything you read on the Internet” is true to a much greater scale with AI. It will say some things that are not true. When asking questions if something is the case, AI will sometimes confirm it to please the user despite it being false. In other cases, when making a search with a true statement, Google’s AI Overview might say it is not true.


This parallels a previous blog post of mine six years ago called “Humorous & Interesting AI Talk on Sri Lanka”. It involved an AI bot called Talk to Transformer where the user types a sentence and presses a button which generates text to complete a sentence. I posted my blog post just after Talk to Transformer was discontinued. It consisted of generated content about Sri Lanka on that service. A lot of what Talk to Transformer said was not true. Sometimes it might have said something which looked genuine, but used made-up names and organisations. A common thread was it being often funny. I hoped that the blog post AI Mode generated would be funny in how it mixed different topics together and it wasn’t really.


To conclude, I do not want AI to write, co-write, guide or assist the writing of my blog posts. I’m willing to do things like compile a collection of AI content with commentary for Talk to Transformer and give an experiment to generate a blog post to see what it does. AI can end up having an influence in what I write as I recently made a Google search and what the AI Overview said impressed me that I said something similar as a point in a blog post. I just don’t want AI writing my blog posts for me or being involved in it. This blog is about my interests and it needs to be organic and sincere. This 125th blog post of mine is coming out 10.5 years after I began The S Blog.

Saturday, 30 May 2026

Heartland Rock Piano

As the piano is my favourite instrument and I listen to a lot of heartland rock, I decided to write an article discussing the heartland rock piano sound. I mention the use of piano in heartland rock songs ranging from big hits to album tracks. I’ll start with the song “American Storm” by Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band. Bill’s piano contributes wonderfully to the full band sound with his playing. The piano notes go up the scale in a very heartland rock way. In their other song “The Ring”, it’s led by the piano of Silver Bullet Band keyboardist Craig Frost. Craig brings an epic feel with his playing and has two solos. The Ring fuses heartland rock with pop rock.

The Ring - Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band (1986)

Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers had a piano-driven hit “Don't Do Me Like That”. Keyboardist Benmont Tench gives a memorable jolly piano part. Nearly a decade later, their song “Jammin’ Me” is a different type of heartland rock song. Benmont brings rock & roll piano sounds into a heartland rock setting. I love what the piano does in the chorus. In Billy Joel’s hit “Allentown”, he leads the song greatly with his piano playing. There is a great piano riff throughout the song.

Don’t Do Me Like That - Tom Petty & The Heartbreakers (1979)

Cleveland heartland rock singer Michael Stanley had released music both with the Michael Stanley Band and solo. When keyboardist Kevin Raleigh joined the band, he was a songwriter and co-lead singer. The songs I’m featuring have two keyboardists Kevin Raleigh and Bob Pelander. They both contributed piano and I don’t know who was the piano player for each song. I wonder if Kevin played piano on the songs he wrote and Bob played the piano on the songs Michael wrote. Last Night, written by both Michael and Kevin is opened by the piano which has a majestic presence on this song. There is a section in the song where the piano notes go up and down in an epic rocking way.

Last Night - Michael Stanley Band (1979)

Promises, a Kevin Raleigh written song has the verses sung by Michael with the choruses seemingly sung by both Kevin and Michael. The piano is lively and energetic. There is a nice glissando after the first chorus. The song “Lover” has a nice piano riff which comes in following the guitar intro. The piano part isn’t the loudest, but it contributes greatly to the song’s sound. My Town is an epic rocker about Michael’s hometown. While this is a guitar-driven song, the piano provides good support including prominent notes during the choruses. How Can You Call This Love written and sung by Kevin has powerful rocking piano playing. The piano goes fast with deep notes.

How Can You Call This Love - Michael Stanley Band (1983)

Bruce Springsteen’s piano player Roy Bittan played wonderful jolly piano on Bruce’s hits “Hungry Heart” and “Glory Days’. Roy gives those songs a great upbeat feel with his playing. Singer Southside Johnny’s song “It’s Been a Long Time” has three lead vocalists with the other two being Bruce and Bruce’s E Street Band guitarist Steven Van Zandt. Southside Johnny & the Asbury Jukes keyboardist Rusty Cloud provides a good musical base with his piano. Bruce Springsteen wrote, was one of the producers and his E Street Band played on the song “This Little Girl” by Gary U.S. Bonds. Roy’s piano fuses rock & roll and heartland rock sounds. He brings a similar jolly sound to what he brought to the Bruce songs I mentioned. I’ll continue mentioning other artists Roy played for.

Glory Days - Bruce Springsteen (1984)

On the Dire Straits song “Skateaway”, Roy’s piano comes about a minute into the song. Roy alternates between slow playing and fast playing. In the choruses, Roy plays in an epic way with his piano rocking in sync with the drums. Roy is driving the heartland rock sound of this song. In Dire Straits' more popular song “Romeo and Juliet” from the same album, Roy plays melodically. Roy’s strongest moments in the song have a very heartland rock feel. He backs Mark Knopfler’s guitars (which are both acoustic and electric) very well. Michael Stanley did a very good cover of this song. He’s an American heartland rock artist covering a heartland rock song by an English band going back musically to where it came from. The piano by Bob Pelander is more prominent than the original. Some people will hate what I’m about to say. I think it’s better than the original.

Skateaway - Dire Straits (1980)

Even Now is my favourite Bob Seger song. It’s one of his forgotten US hits. Roy’s piano goes up and down the scale in an incredible way. The piano matches greatly with Bob’s vocals with there being sections where Roy’s notes seem to be a musical response to what Bob sang. On “Roll Me Away”, another hit from the same album, Roy gives us majestic rocking piano. Another song Roy played for Bob is “The Fire Inside”, an epic rock song nearly six minutes long. It’s led by the piano and the fact that the guitar part is acoustic gives more room for the piano to rock. Roy’s piano is incredible and detailed which includes two solos.

The Fire Inside - Bob Seger & The Silver Bullet Band (1991)

On Jackson Browne’s “Here Come Those Tears Again”, Bill Payne plays piano in a warm way. The piano gives off its heartland rock vibes in the way the notes jump from one place to another. Jackson Browne’s epic rock song “The Fuse” has Craig Doerge play incredible heartland rock piano. Craig’s piano has deep dark notes that are so effective. The piano goes very well with David Lindley’s slide guitar. I love how Jackson fuses piano and guitar in a heartland rock setting in many of his songs. Jackson’s classic song “The Pretender” has rich piano from Craig. In parts of the song, the piano shifts from one note to another. 

The Pretender - Jackson Browne (1976)

Running on Empty is a faster rock song driven more by guitar, but Craig’s piano is still a big part of the song. It has an iconic piano opening. Craig incorporates rock & roll influences while maintaining the heartland rock sound. That Girl Could Sing is a case where Jackson played piano on one of his own songs. Jackson’s piano is catchy and has both slower and faster sections. In “For America”, the piano by Jai Winding has sections going back and forth between musical notes. It also has a few short parts led by the piano. Jai’s piano holds this guitar-driven song together very well. Jackson’s lyrics are thought provoking, especially in relation to America’s current issues and 250th anniversary.

That Girl Could Sing - Jackson Browe (1980)

So far these songs by classic rock artists were in the 20th century, with most of them being in the 70s and 80s. I’ll now feature three 21st century songs from classic rock artists. In Michael Stanley’s solo song “My Brand New Day”, Bob Pelander offers amazing, rich piano playing filled with depth. Elton John did a rare case of a heartland rock song in “England and America” ten years ago. Elton showcases his brilliant piano skills by playing different to the way he normally plays where he nails the heartland rock piano sound. Bob Seger’s “Forward Into the Past” is a guitar-driven song, but it’s supported well by Bill Payne’s piano. Bill brings out prominent piano notes in parts of the song which contribute greatly to its rock sound.

My Brand New Day - Michael Stanley (2009)

Companion Articles
I’m providing links to previous articles of mine which are companion articles as they discuss some of the same songs.


These songs show the prominent place piano has in heartland rock music. I like the fact that many of them feature a piano/organ combination. They cover a wide range on the rock spectrum going from soft to hard rock. Some of them fuse heartland rock with other styles such as rock & roll and pop rock. Most of the songs are by American artists, but I did include two English artists. They are Dire Straits and Elton John who fuse English rock with American heartland rock in the songs of theirs I featured. Elton’s song is apt for this as it’s literally about England and America. Heartland rock is a genre which has some epic long rock songs like “The Pretender” and “The Fire Inside”. I’d be interested in hearing what you think of the heartland rock piano sound.